Meat processors warn CO2 pig stunning phase-out could undermine British food security

The British Meat Processors Association says Defra should have commissioned research into viable alternatives before consulting on ending CO2 stunning of pigs, warning a ban could shrink processing capacity and increase reliance on imported pork.

The British Meat Processors Association (BMPA) has warned that government plans to phase out the use of carbon dioxide to stun pigs before slaughter could undermine British food security, arguing that no proven, commercially viable alternative yet exists.

Pigs at St Werburghs City Farm in Bristol. Photo: Derek Harper / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).
Pigs at St Werburghs City Farm in Bristol. Photo: Derek Harper / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).

The trade body, whose members include some of the largest companies in the British meat industry, was responding to Defra's consultation, set out this week by Farming Minister Stephen Morgan, on moving the pork sector towards methods such as argon gas and automated electrical stunning. The consultation runs until 21 December.

BMPA says it supports the highest standards of animal welfare, but that ministers are proposing a major change without first establishing whether alternatives can deliver better welfare outcomes while keeping Britain's pig processing industry running at the scale needed.

Powell: 'Research should have come first'

John Powell, Chief Executive of BMPA, said: "We fully support improving animal welfare, but Defra should have commissioned the necessary research before launching this consultation. At present, there is no proven, commercially viable alternative to CO2 that can maintain the throughput required by British pig processors and the supply demanded by British consumers."

"Without a viable alternative to CO2, we risk reducing domestic processing capacity, undermining British pig farming and becoming more reliant on imported pork from countries that continue to use CO2 as a tried and tested method of stunning. At a time when food security is already under pressure, that would be deeply irresponsible," he said.

Concerns over competitiveness with Europe

Powell also questioned the timing, pointing to the UK's closeness to a sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement with the EU. "We are surprised that the Government has launched this consultation now, as we are so close to an SPS agreement with the EU, which will dramatically improve our competitiveness. The EU is not currently proposing a similar ban so, if a ban on CO2 is introduced in the UK, it will dramatically decrease our competitiveness," he said.

The association also rejects the idea that concerns over CO2 supply justify a phase-out, saying that despite modest price rises linked to the Iran conflict, supplies to the sector have not been disrupted and the gas makes up a relatively small share of food production costs.

Calling for a whole-pathway assessment of the welfare, economic and practical consequences before any decision is taken, Powell said that if research identifies a genuinely better and commercially viable method, industry will need a realistic transition period to invest and adapt. "Until then, phasing out CO2 is neither practical nor responsible. We cannot afford to gamble with animal welfare or Britain's food security," he said.

Showing 1 reaction

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • published this page in News 2026-10-27 11:26:53 +0000

Share this article

Meat processors warn CO2 pig stunning phase-out could undermine British food security

Meat processors warn CO2 pig stunning phase-out could undermine British food security